[Bp_ipv6] Scheduling an initial call; gentle reminder for feedback on Scope and Goals

Izumi Okutani izumi at nic.ad.jp
Wed May 20 21:12:48 EDT 2015


Excellent Natalie. This feedback is very helpful.

This is certainly a good example of a specific measure in creating an environment to encourage IPv6 adoption.
I note RIPE NCC have several experiences on how IPv6 Task Force has helped create an environment for IPv6 adoption and looking forward to have more discussions at the Webex call.

Does anyone have any other comments about the scope and the goals and/or measures and activities which you think would be good to be incorporated in the document?
Receiving these inputs online before the call help others to comment while inputs directly at the call is certainly welcome as well. Thanks!


Izumi

On 2015/05/20 19:06, Nathalie Trenaman wrote:
> Hi all,
> 
> Thank you very much for inviting me to the discussion. I look forward to the Webex call tomorrow.
> As a scope, I suggested to Izumi we might look at the important role of local IPv6 Task forces, how they helped with spreading knowledge, building communities and pushing IPv6 deployments.
> I think governments and (commercial) organisations could benefit greatly from a local IPv6 Task force, as we have seen in a number of countries already. These local task forces also exchange knowledge and promote local deployments on a more regional level, at different conferences for example.
> 
> I agree that technical best practices should be outside the scope of this document. 
> 
> Many thanks,
> 
> Nathalie K�nneke-Trenaman
> IPv6 Program Manager
> RIPE NCC 
> 
> 
> On 13 May 2015, at 11:12, Susan Chalmers <susan at chalmers.associates> wrote:
> 
>> Dear all,
>>
>> We would like to schedule an introductory call next week to discuss the Scope and Goals of the Best Practice Forum on IPv6 Adoption.
>>
>> A few of us will find ourselves in the same spot for the MAG meetings in Geneva, and we reckon this would be a good opportunity to coordinate discussion and plan. The IGF Secretariat will provide WebEx facilities for our call.
>>
>> Could you kindly fill the Doodle poll, indicating your availability to join a WebEx call? The link to the poll is: http://doodle.com/9hxuhmuqczc8p6rk
>>
>> Also, this is a gentle reminder for your feedback on the Scope and Goals; its purpose is to provide helpful orientation for participants. Please let us know your thoughts on the below:
>>
>> Scope and Goals for the BPF on IPv6 Adoption
>>
>> Introduction
>> Widespread adoption of IPv6 will be important to maintaining the global reach and integrity of the Internet. Following this wide-spread adoption, the eventual transition to IPv6 will only be successful when we, as a community, are all moving together at the same time. Adoption of IPv6 by a single entity is often a challenge; it is not useful if one organization alone adopts IPv6 when majority of the Internet is based on IPv4. The long-term sustainability of the network and success of the Internet to accommodate IPv6 depends on getting more organisations to adopt IPv6. 
>>
>> By documenting best practices regarding measures and activities for creating an environment that accommodates IPv6 adoption, we hope to provide the global Internet community with helpful information that can help guide stakeholders in this exercise.
>>
>> There are ways in which different stakeholders with different roles can each contribute to IPv6 adoption. This Best Practice Forum gives all stakeholders the opportunity to contribute. 
>>
>> Purpose
>> The Purpose of the 2015 Internet Governance Forum Best Practice Forum on IPv6 Adoption is to document best practices on activities and measures for an environment that supports IPv6 adoption, which we will share through open, multistakeholder discussion on the dedicated mailing list.
>>
>> Guiding principles
>> Participants are encouraged to share real-life stories of successful and, more importantly, unsuccessful initiatives for IPv6 adoption; we oftentimes learn a great deal from unsuccessful experiences.
>> The Forum discussion is open to all who are interested and willing to contribute constructively, guided by these Scope and Goals;
>> The Forum should avoid duplication of the work already being conducted;
>> The focus of Forum discussion should be on practical information sharing, rather than theory;
>> The information we will compile should be neutral, not for commercial promotion.
>>
>> Scope
>> As an Internet issue, IPv6 adoption encompasses a broad range of sub-issues, affecting multiple actors and different stakeholders. It will be helpful to define the scope of our discussion at the outset, for a more focused dialogue.
>>
>> The scope of the BPF on IPv6 Adoption discussion will focus on the best practices on measures and activities for an environment which supports IPv6 adoption, and, in particular, measures and activities taken at global, regional and local levels.
>> Technical best practices on IPv6 adoption, which are covered by existing efforts by experts in this area, is outside of the scope of this group.
>>
>> Working methodology
>> The discussions at the BPF on IPv6 will be guided by Technical Community MAG members Izumi Okutani, Susan Chalmers, and German Valdez. 
>> The designated mailing list will be the primary working channel of the BPF on IPv6. Information on the mailing list is available here: http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/bp_ipv6_intgovforum.org
>> The group will likely convene WebEx calls from time to time, with the assistance of the IGF Secretariat.
>> The final document will be produced by a consultant engaged by the IGF Secretariat.
>>
>> Questions
>> Do you think the above information is sufficient for a general Scope and Goals description? What do you think is missing? What do you think can be removed?
>> In terms of Scope, there are a number of ways in which we can further refine the document - for example by focusing on one or more group needing best practices according to their situation. Below are three suggestions to kick start discussion:
>> Creating a reference for governments looking to create an enabling environment for IPv6 adoption by industry players in their economy;
>> Creating a reference for someone looking for community/collaborative efforts to promote IPv6 adoption in collaboration with key stakeholders in their community;
>> Creating a reference for someone considering IPv6 adoption in their network but do not know the resources to look for.
>>
>> Many thanks, all the best, and we hope to hear from you soon!
>>
>> Sincerely,
>> Susan Chalmers
>>
>>
>>
>> Susan Chalmers
>> susan at chalmers.associates
>>
>> CHALMERS & ASSOCIATES
>> http://chalmers.associates
>> _______________________________________________
>> Bp_ipv6 mailing list
>> Bp_ipv6 at intgovforum.org
>> http://intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/bp_ipv6_intgovforum.org
> 
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Bp_ipv6 mailing list
> Bp_ipv6 at intgovforum.org
> http://intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/bp_ipv6_intgovforum.org
> 





More information about the Bp_ipv6 mailing list