[IGFmaglist] Next Steps: Way Forward Evolution of Internet Governance Ecosystem/Role of IGF – (Reaction to NETmundial + CSTD, WSIS, ITU, other fora.)
Subi Chaturvedi
subichaturvedi at gmail.com
Wed Apr 16 07:43:09 EDT 2014
Agree Fiona entirely.
Have collated the inputs. Do please send in your suggestions too on the
session.
warmest
Subi
----
Subi Chaturvedi
Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm,
Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR),
Delhi University, India
M:+91-9999151433
Twitter:@subichaturvedi
Skype:subi.apex
Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society)
Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society)
Convenor WG-India IGF
Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society)
Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee,
Media For Change
Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor
The Saltlist
www.thesaltlist.org
Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer,
Curator, Media Critic & Scholar
PhD. Scholar,
Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi
On 16 April 2014 17:05, Fiona Alexander <FAlexander at ntia.doc.gov> wrote:
> Just to highlight there is far more to ICANN than the IANA transition
> issue, perhaps it is to those elements Marilyn and others are pointing to
> as including in this session.
>
> Fiona
>
>
> -------- Original message --------
> From: Subi Chaturvedi
> Date:04/16/2014 7:32 AM (GMT-05:00)
> To: Filiz Yilmaz
> Cc: MAG List IGF ,evolintgov2014
> Subject: Re: [IGFmaglist] Next Steps: Way Forward Evolution of Internet
> Governance Ecosystem/Role of IGF – (Reaction to NETmundial + CSTD, WSIS,
> ITU, other fora.)
>
> Thanks Filiz. Excellent inputs. Let me explain so that we can all be on
> the same page. I meant Marilyn might have missed the poll and therefore
> might not be aware that there is a separate session dedicated to
> specifically the IANA transition/ICANN part of the IG way forward. Your
> name you would notice is already a part of the original list on the mail
> even in this thread, taken from the doodle poll. so no confusion there.
> That also doesn't indicate that other than the volunteers who signed up
> the MAG members shouldn't contribute. On the contrary I continue to ask for
> inputs from all the MAG members. Additionally I have already requested the
> secretariat to add Marilyn to the mailing list created for this session.
>
> evolintgov2014 <evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org>
>
> Your time and your inputs are most valued and deeply appreciated.
>
> Now here are some quick points on the sessions planing thus far:
>
>
> At stage 1 all these issues were a part of this session, when it was
> envisaged originally as one big main .
>
> At stage 2 and over the virtual call the chair suggested that we keep
> the two sessions separate and we decided to have two main sessions on the
> Internet ecosystem instead of one, so that we can have a more focused
> discussion in both the sessions. I have no preference one way or the other
> and we should certainly decided on the strands today if possible over the
> virtual call or over emails.
>
>
> All inputs and suggestions are very welcome. You would notice that not
> only do I agree that we should have more speakers from all organisations
> but also from different stakeholder groups
>
> .Civil Society/Academia
> .Technical community
> .Governments
> .Private sector
>
> I continue to ask for names of speakers/ recommendations from all the
> organisations and from across stakeholder groups. Excellent suggestions all
> from you, Marilyn, Tero, Bill, Izumi and Olga. Thank you all.
>
> Do please suggest speakers/facilitators and your inputs on the other
> items we need to take a decision on.
>
> Looking forward.
>
>
> warmest
>
> Subi
> ----
>
> Subi Chaturvedi
>
> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm,
>
> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR),
>
> Delhi University, India
>
> M:+91-9999151433
>
> Twitter:@subichaturvedi
>
> Skype:subi.apex
>
>
> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society)
>
> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society)
>
> Convenor WG-India IGF
>
> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society)
>
>
> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee,
>
> Media For Change
>
>
> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor
>
> The Saltlist
>
> www.thesaltlist.org
>
>
> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer,
>
> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar
>
>
> PhD. Scholar,
>
> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi
>
>
>
> On 16 April 2014 16:30, Filiz Yilmaz <koalafil at gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Hi Subi,
>>
>> No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences.
>> I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up
>> doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up
>> those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be
>> a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that
>> this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions
>> that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for
>> the general invitation to do so.
>>
>> I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main
>> session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap” in its
>> description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF,
>> and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail.
>>
>> I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like
>> ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc… further on the following:
>>
>>
>>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may
>>> be requested if they consent (suggestion)
>>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Touré,
>>> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion)
>>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the
>>> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial)
>>> (suggestion)
>>>
>>>
>> then this would remedy my concerns.
>>
>> Kind regards
>> Filiz Yilmaz
>>
>>
>> On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi <subichaturvedi at gmail.com>
>> wrote:
>>
>> Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as
>> always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the
>> nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for
>> pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular ,
>> ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a
>> separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective
>> decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have
>> missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two
>> separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them
>> here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall
>> Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize
>> and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder
>> group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of
>> us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since
>> this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together
>> on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG
>> landscape.
>>
>> I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their
>> deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on
>> the mailing list created for the session.
>>
>> The id for the mailing list for this session is
>> evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org
>>
>> Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement.
>>
>> To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the
>> timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to:
>>
>> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items
>>
>> MAIN FOCUS SESSION:
>> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have
>> signed up.
>> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be
>> required but mostly relates to the points above
>> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required
>> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required
>> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs
>> required
>> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call
>> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required
>> Stage-8: Feedback and review
>>
>>
>> Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you.
>>
>>
>> warmest
>>
>> Subi
>> ----
>>
>> Subi Chaturvedi
>>
>> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm,
>>
>> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR),
>>
>> Delhi University, India
>>
>> M:+91-9999151433
>>
>> Twitter:@subichaturvedi
>>
>>
>> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society)
>>
>> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society)
>>
>> Convenor WG-India IGF
>>
>> Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society)
>>
>>
>> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee,
>>
>> Media For Change
>>
>>
>> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor
>>
>> The Saltlist
>>
>> www.thesaltlist.org
>>
>>
>> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer,
>>
>> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar
>>
>>
>> PhD. Scholar,
>>
>> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi
>>
>>
>>
>> On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade <marilynscade at hotmail.com> wrote:
>>
>>> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco
>>> is also high priority to include .
>>> I would suggest slight re formulation
>>>
>>> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review
>>> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO)
>>> NETmundial outputs
>>>
>>> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c
>>>
>>> Is that what we want to do?
>>>
>>> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated.
>>>
>>> Sent from my iPhone
>>>
>>> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" <subichaturvedi at gmail.com>
>>> wrote:
>>>
>>> Dear All,
>>>
>>> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have
>>> indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main
>>> focus session.
>>>
>>> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual
>>> call.
>>>
>>> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus
>>> session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to
>>> receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead
>>> of the next scheduled call.
>>>
>>> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have
>>> been identified for this session:
>>>
>>>
>>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF)
>>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14)
>>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the
>>> future roadmap
>>>
>>> And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the
>>> values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity,
>>> integrity, freedom of speech and expression,
>>> universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation
>>> and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses
>>> and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles
>>> and the internet of the future.
>>>
>>> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items
>>>
>>> MAIN FOCUS SESSION:
>>> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have
>>> signed up.
>>> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be
>>> required but mostly relates to the points above
>>> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required
>>> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required
>>> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs
>>> required
>>> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call
>>> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required
>>> Stage-8: Feedback and review
>>>
>>> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the
>>> IGF secretariat, as requested.
>>>
>>> Some speaker suggestions
>>>
>>>
>>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may
>>> be requested if they consent (suggestion)
>>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Touré,
>>> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion)
>>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the
>>> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial)
>>> (suggestion)
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for
>>> your constructive feedback and valuable inputs.
>>>
>>>
>>> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the
>>> list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too.
>>>
>>> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference
>>> and committing your time.
>>>
>>> List:
>>>
>>> 1. Olga Cavall
>>> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser
>>> 3.Subi Chaturvedi
>>> 4.Virat Bhatia
>>> 5.Ana Neves
>>> 6.Constance Bommelaer
>>> 7.Kossi Amessinou
>>> 8.Baher Esmat
>>> 9.Izumi Aizu
>>> 10.Shahram Soboutipour
>>> 11.William Drake
>>> 12.Jivan
>>> 13.Patrick Ryan
>>> 14.Ankhi Das
>>> 15.Christine Arida
>>>
>>>
>>> warmest
>>>
>>> Subi
>>> ----
>>>
>>> Subi Chaturvedi
>>>
>>> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm,
>>>
>>> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR),
>>>
>>> Delhi University, India
>>>
>>> M:+91-9999151433
>>>
>>> Twitter:@subichaturvedi
>>>
>>> Skype:subi.apex
>>>
>>>
>>> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society)
>>>
>>> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society)
>>>
>>> Convenor WG-India IGF
>>>
>>> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society)
>>>
>>>
>>> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee,
>>>
>>> Media For Change
>>>
>>>
>>> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor
>>>
>>> The Saltlist
>>>
>>> www.thesaltlist.org
>>>
>>>
>>> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer,
>>>
>>> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar
>>>
>>>
>>> PhD. Scholar,
>>>
>>> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Igfmaglist mailing list
>>> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org
>>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org
>>>
>>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Igfmaglist mailing list
>> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org
>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org
>>
>>
>>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://intgovforum.org/pipermail/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org/attachments/20140416/135716cd/attachment.htm>
More information about the Igfmaglist
mailing list