From amessinoukossi at yahoo.fr Mon Apr 14 09:32:48 2014 From: amessinoukossi at yahoo.fr (Kossi Amessinou) Date: Mon, 14 Apr 2014 14:32:48 +0100 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] availability Message-ID: Happy to contribute to the discussion on this group. -- AMESSINOU Kossi Ing?nieur TIC ICT Engineer Contact: 00229 95 19 67 02 skype: amessinou @amessinou @bigf http://www.facebook.com/amessinoukossi www.linkedin.com/pub/kossi-amessinou Que Dieu vous b?nisse. Dans le silence, Dieu nous parle! -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subichaturvedi at gmail.com Mon Apr 14 09:59:35 2014 From: subichaturvedi at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Mon, 14 Apr 2014 19:29:35 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?Next_Steps=3A_Way_Forward_Evolution_of?= =?utf-8?q?_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_=E2=80=93_=28?= =?utf-8?q?Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_other_fo?= =?utf-8?q?ra=2E=29?= Message-ID: Dear All, Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and the way forward main focus session. This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. And to invite all of you to participate in the planning of the Main Focus session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem- Main Focus Session. Would be delighted to receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting. In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been identified for this session: 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, integrity, freedom of speech and expression, universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles and the internet of the future. NEXT STEPS:- Action Items MAIN FOCUS SESSION: Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-8: Feedback and review The Main is slotted for DAY III morning very kindly by the IGF secretariat, as requested. Some speaker suggestions 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From wjdrake at gmail.com Tue Apr 15 05:16:29 2014 From: wjdrake at gmail.com (William Drake) Date: Tue, 15 Apr 2014 11:16:29 +0200 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?windows-1252?q?Next_Steps=3A_Way_Forward_Evolu?= =?windows-1252?q?tion_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_=96_?= =?windows-1252?q?=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_other?= =?windows-1252?q?_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: Hi On Apr 14, 2014, at 3:59 PM, Subi Chaturvedi wrote: > UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) > ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) > Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) All fine and eminently qualified folks, but I would suggest that we have speakers from civil society, business, and the technical community as well, somehow without having much more than six on the panel if we want to allow room for open discussion with the floor. Best, Bill -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From olgacavalli at gmail.com Tue Apr 15 16:22:20 2014 From: olgacavalli at gmail.com (Olga Cavalli) Date: Tue, 15 Apr 2014 17:22:20 -0300 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?Next_Steps=3A_Way_Forward_Evolution_of?= =?utf-8?q?_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_=E2=80=93_=28?= =?utf-8?q?Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_other_fo?= =?utf-8?q?ra=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: +1 to Bill?s comments best Olga 2014-04-15 6:16 GMT-03:00 William Drake : > Hi > > On Apr 14, 2014, at 3:59 PM, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: > > > 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may > be requested if they consent (suggestion) > 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, > Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) > 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the > future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) > (suggestion) > > > All fine and eminently qualified folks, but I would suggest that we have > speakers from civil society, business, and the technical community as well, > somehow without having much more than six on the panel if we want to allow > room for open discussion with the floor. > > Best, > > Bill > > > > _______________________________________________ > Evolintgov2014 mailing list > Evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/evolintgov2014_intgovforum.org > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From iza at anr.org Tue Apr 15 21:22:13 2014 From: iza at anr.org (Izumi AIZU) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 10:22:13 +0900 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?Next_Steps=3A_Way_Forward_Evolution_of?= =?utf-8?q?_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_=E2=80=93_=28?= =?utf-8?q?Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_other_fo?= =?utf-8?q?ra=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: I strongly support BIll's comment/suggestion. Include some major and different views expressed at NETMundial discuss list, for example. izumi 2014-04-16 5:22 GMT+09:00 Olga Cavalli : > +1 to Bill?s comments > best > Olga > > > 2014-04-15 6:16 GMT-03:00 William Drake : > >> Hi >> >> On Apr 14, 2014, at 3:59 PM, Subi Chaturvedi >> wrote: >> >> >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >> (suggestion) >> >> >> All fine and eminently qualified folks, but I would suggest that we have >> speakers from civil society, business, and the technical community as well, >> somehow without having much more than six on the panel if we want to allow >> room for open discussion with the floor. >> >> Best, >> >> Bill >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Evolintgov2014 mailing list >> Evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org >> >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/evolintgov2014_intgovforum.org >> >> > > _______________________________________________ > Evolintgov2014 mailing list > Evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/evolintgov2014_intgovforum.org > > -- >> Izumi Aizu << Institute for InfoSocionomics, Tama University, Tokyo Institute for HyperNetwork Society, Oita, Japan www.anr.org -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subichaturvedi at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 00:10:03 2014 From: subichaturvedi at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 09:40:03 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?Next_Steps=3A_Way_Forward_Evolution_of?= =?utf-8?q?_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_=E2=80=93_=28?= =?utf-8?q?Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_other_fo?= =?utf-8?q?ra=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: Many thanks Bill. For your excellent inputs.I completely agree with you and hence the call for more names of suggested speakers, inputs on format and suggested speakers. Since we have 3 strands, we'll need speakers from stakeholder groups on all the strands. I didn't at all mean to suggested that they'll be the only speakers on those strands and these also names by way of suggestions. The panel or whichever format that we collectively decide to go with, could also be a roundtable has to be multistakehlder with voices from. 1. Academia 2. Civil Society 3.Government 4.Private Sector 5.Technical Community With plenty of time for engagement/inputs from across the floor. Keeping to 6 might be difficult though but we can change the format to keep it more interactive. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 15 April 2014 14:46, William Drake wrote: > Hi > > On Apr 14, 2014, at 3:59 PM, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: > > > 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may > be requested if they consent (suggestion) > 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, > Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) > 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the > future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) > (suggestion) > > > All fine and eminently qualified folks, but I would suggest that we have > speakers from civil society, business, and the technical community as well, > somehow without having much more than six on the panel if we want to allow > room for open discussion with the floor. > > Best, > > Bill > > > > _______________________________________________ > Evolintgov2014 mailing list > Evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/evolintgov2014_intgovforum.org > > \ -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subichaturvedi at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 00:21:28 2014 From: subichaturvedi at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 09:51:28 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?Next_Steps=3A_Way_Forward_Evolution_of?= =?utf-8?q?_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_=E2=80=93_=28?= =?utf-8?q?Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_other_fo?= =?utf-8?q?ra=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: thanks Izumi I support Bill's inputs equally strongly. And that would be the only way to approach this. Waiting to hear more from you. Your inputs are extremely valuable. NEXT STEPS:- Action Items MAIN FOCUS SESSION: Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-8: Feedback and review warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 16 April 2014 06:52, Izumi AIZU wrote: > I strongly support BIll's comment/suggestion. > > Include some major and different views expressed at NETMundial discuss > list, for example. > > > izumi > > > 2014-04-16 5:22 GMT+09:00 Olga Cavalli : > > +1 to Bill?s comments >> best >> Olga >> >> >> 2014-04-15 6:16 GMT-03:00 William Drake : >> >>> Hi >>> >>> On Apr 14, 2014, at 3:59 PM, Subi Chaturvedi >>> wrote: >>> >>> >>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >>> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >>> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >>> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >>> (suggestion) >>> >>> >>> All fine and eminently qualified folks, but I would suggest that we have >>> speakers from civil society, business, and the technical community as well, >>> somehow without having much more than six on the panel if we want to allow >>> room for open discussion with the floor. >>> >>> Best, >>> >>> Bill >>> >>> >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Evolintgov2014 mailing list >>> Evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org >>> >>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/evolintgov2014_intgovforum.org >>> >>> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Evolintgov2014 mailing list >> Evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org >> >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/evolintgov2014_intgovforum.org >> >> > > > -- > >> Izumi Aizu << > Institute for InfoSocionomics, Tama University, Tokyo > Institute for HyperNetwork Society, Oita, > Japan > www.anr.org > > _______________________________________________ > Evolintgov2014 mailing list > Evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/evolintgov2014_intgovforum.org > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subichaturvedi at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 06:47:02 2014 From: subichaturvedi at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 16:17:02 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_Way_For?= =?utf-8?q?ward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_?= =?utf-8?q?IGF_=E2=80=93_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS?= =?utf-8?q?=2C_ITU=2C_other_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG landscape. I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the mailing list created for the session. The id for the mailing list for this session is evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: NEXT STEPS:- Action Items MAIN FOCUS SESSION: Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-8: Feedback and review Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: > I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is > also high priority to include . > I would suggest slight re formulation > > Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review > UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) > NETmundial outputs > > Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c > > Is that what we want to do? > > Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" > wrote: > > Dear All, > > Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have > indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main > focus session. > > This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. > > And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus > session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to > receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead > of the next scheduled call. > > In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been > identified for this session: > > > 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) > 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) > 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the > future roadmap > > And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the > values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, > integrity, freedom of speech and expression, > universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation > and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses > and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles > and the internet of the future. > > NEXT STEPS:- Action Items > > MAIN FOCUS SESSION: > Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have > signed up. > Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required > but mostly relates to the points above > Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs > required > Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call > Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-8: Feedback and review > > The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the > IGF secretariat, as requested. > > Some speaker suggestions > > > 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may > be requested if they consent (suggestion) > 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, > Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) > 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the > future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) > (suggestion) > > > > Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your > constructive feedback and valuable inputs. > > > Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the > list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. > > Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and > committing your time. > > List: > > 1. Olga Cavall > 2.Anriette Esterhuyser > 3.Subi Chaturvedi > 4.Virat Bhatia > 5.Ana Neves > 6.Constance Bommelaer > 7.Kossi Amessinou > 8.Baher Esmat > 9.Izumi Aizu > 10.Shahram Soboutipour > 11.William Drake > 12.Jivan > 13.Patrick Ryan > 14.Ankhi Das > 15.Christine Arida > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > Skype:subi.apex > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > _______________________________________________ > Igfmaglist mailing list > Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From bommelaer at isoc.org Wed Apr 16 07:28:09 2014 From: bommelaer at isoc.org (Constance Bommelaer) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 11:28:09 +0000 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?windows-1252?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_?= =?windows-1252?q?Way_Forward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/R?= =?windows-1252?q?ole_of_IGF_=AD_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS?= =?windows-1252?q?=2C_ITU=2C_other_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> References: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> Message-ID: Dear Subi et all, I support suggestions made by Filiz, Marilyn and others to adopt a comprehensive approach and not solely focus on the inter-governmental elements of the Internet ecosystem. Looking forward to our discussion today. Best regards, Constance From: Filiz Yilmaz > Date: Wednesday, April 16, 2014 1:00 PM To: Subi Chaturvedi > Cc: MAG List IGF >, evolintgov2014 > Subject: Re: [IGFmaglist] Next Steps: Way Forward Evolution of Internet Governance Ecosystem/Role of IGF ? (Reaction to NETmundial + CSTD, WSIS, ITU, other fora.) Hi Subi, No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for the general invitation to do so. I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) then this would remedy my concerns. Kind regards Filiz Yilmaz On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG landscape. I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the mailing list created for the session. The id for the mailing list for this session is evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: NEXT STEPS:- Action Items MAIN FOCUS SESSION: Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-8: Feedback and review Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade > wrote: I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is also high priority to include . I would suggest slight re formulation Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) NETmundial outputs Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c Is that what we want to do? Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. Sent from my iPhone On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" > wrote: Dear All, Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main focus session. This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead of the next scheduled call. In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been identified for this session: 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap And all of these would lead to best practices related to the core the values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, integrity, freedom of speech and expression, universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles and the internet of the future. NEXT STEPS:- Action Items MAIN FOCUS SESSION: Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-8: Feedback and review The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the IGF secretariat, as requested. Some speaker suggestions 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and committing your time. List: 1. Olga Cavall 2.Anriette Esterhuyser 3.Subi Chaturvedi 4.Virat Bhatia 5.Ana Neves 6.Constance Bommelaer 7.Kossi Amessinou 8.Baher Esmat 9.Izumi Aizu 10.Shahram Soboutipour 11.William Drake 12.Jivan 13.Patrick Ryan 14.Ankhi Das 15.Christine Arida warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi _______________________________________________ Igfmaglist mailing list Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org _______________________________________________ Igfmaglist mailing list Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subichaturvedi at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 07:31:02 2014 From: subichaturvedi at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 17:01:02 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_Way_For?= =?utf-8?q?ward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_?= =?utf-8?q?IGF_=E2=80=93_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS?= =?utf-8?q?=2C_ITU=2C_other_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> References: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> Message-ID: Thanks Filiz. Excellent inputs. Let me explain so that we can all be on the same page. I meant Marilyn might have missed the poll and therefore might not be aware that there is a separate session dedicated to specifically the IANA transition/ICANN part of the IG way forward. Your name you would notice is already a part of the original list on the mail even in this thread, taken from the doodle poll. so no confusion there. That also doesn't indicate that other than the volunteers who signed up the MAG members shouldn't contribute. On the contrary I continue to ask for inputs from all the MAG members. Additionally I have already requested the secretariat to add Marilyn to the mailing list created for this session. evolintgov2014 Your time and your inputs are most valued and deeply appreciated. Now here are some quick points on the sessions planing thus far: At stage 1 all these issues were a part of this session, when it was envisaged originally as one big main . At stage 2 and over the virtual call the chair suggested that we keep the two sessions separate and we decided to have two main sessions on the Internet ecosystem instead of one, so that we can have a more focused discussion in both the sessions. I have no preference one way or the other and we should certainly decided on the strands today if possible over the virtual call or over emails. All inputs and suggestions are very welcome. You would notice that not only do I agree that we should have more speakers from all organisations but also from different stakeholder groups .Civil Society/Academia .Technical community .Governments .Private sector I continue to ask for names of speakers/ recommendations from all the organisations and from across stakeholder groups. Excellent suggestions all from you, Marilyn, Tero, Bill, Izumi and Olga. Thank you all. Do please suggest speakers/facilitators and your inputs on the other items we need to take a decision on. Looking forward. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 16 April 2014 16:30, Filiz Yilmaz wrote: > Hi Subi, > > No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. > I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up > doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up > those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be > a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that > this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions > that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for > the general invitation to do so. > > I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main > session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its > description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, > and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. > > I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like > ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: > > >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >> (suggestion) >> >> > then this would remedy my concerns. > > Kind regards > Filiz Yilmaz > > > On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: > > Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as > always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the > nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for > pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , > ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a > separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective > decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have > missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two > separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them > here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall > Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize > and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder > group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of > us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since > this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together > on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG > landscape. > > I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply > insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the > mailing list created for the session. > > The id for the mailing list for this session is > evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > > Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. > > To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines > do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: > > NEXT STEPS:- Action Items > > MAIN FOCUS SESSION: > Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have > signed up. > Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required > but mostly relates to the points above > Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs > required > Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call > Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-8: Feedback and review > > > Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: > >> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is >> also high priority to include . >> I would suggest slight re formulation >> >> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review >> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) >> NETmundial outputs >> >> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c >> >> Is that what we want to do? >> >> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. >> >> Sent from my iPhone >> >> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" >> wrote: >> >> Dear All, >> >> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have >> indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main >> focus session. >> >> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. >> >> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus >> session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to >> receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead >> of the next scheduled call. >> >> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been >> identified for this session: >> >> >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap >> >> And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the >> values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, >> integrity, freedom of speech and expression, >> universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation >> and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses >> and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles >> and the internet of the future. >> >> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >> >> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have >> signed up. >> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be >> required but mostly relates to the points above >> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs >> required >> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-8: Feedback and review >> >> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the >> IGF secretariat, as requested. >> >> Some speaker suggestions >> >> >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >> (suggestion) >> >> >> >> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your >> constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >> >> >> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the >> list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >> >> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and >> committing your time. >> >> List: >> >> 1. Olga Cavall >> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >> 4.Virat Bhatia >> 5.Ana Neves >> 6.Constance Bommelaer >> 7.Kossi Amessinou >> 8.Baher Esmat >> 9.Izumi Aizu >> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >> 11.William Drake >> 12.Jivan >> 13.Patrick Ryan >> 14.Ankhi Das >> 15.Christine Arida >> >> >> warmest >> >> Subi >> ---- >> >> Subi Chaturvedi >> >> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >> >> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >> >> Delhi University, India >> >> M:+91-9999151433 >> >> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >> >> Skype:subi.apex >> >> >> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >> >> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >> >> Convenor WG-India IGF >> >> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >> >> >> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >> >> Media For Change >> >> >> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >> >> The Saltlist >> >> www.thesaltlist.org >> >> >> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >> >> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >> >> >> PhD. Scholar, >> >> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Igfmaglist mailing list >> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >> >> > _______________________________________________ > Igfmaglist mailing list > Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subichaturvedi at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 07:38:12 2014 From: subichaturvedi at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 17:08:12 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_Way_For?= =?utf-8?q?ward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_?= =?utf-8?q?IGF_=C2=AD_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_I?= =?utf-8?q?TU=2C_other_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> Message-ID: Dear Constance, thank you for your mail. I wonder where the impression came from. My earlier email clarifies this misunderstanding if any. For this main and for all IGF panels one of foremost pre-requisites has been stakeholder balance, additionally regional diversity and gender balance. We must have a multistakeholder dialogue and I am absolutely certain that this should include all stakeholder groups and organizations. Doing this as an intergovernmental session would be the anti-thesis of the session and the entire IGF process. Something that I am vehemently opposed to. Do please send in your suggestions on speakers from different organisations and stakeholder groups and your recommendations on policy questions as well as the format of the session. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 16 April 2014 16:58, Constance Bommelaer wrote: > Dear Subi et all, > > I support suggestions made by Filiz, Marilyn and others to adopt a > comprehensive approach and not solely focus on the inter-governmental > elements of the Internet ecosystem. > > Looking forward to our discussion today. > > Best regards, > > Constance > > > > From: Filiz Yilmaz > Date: Wednesday, April 16, 2014 1:00 PM > To: Subi Chaturvedi > Cc: MAG List IGF , evolintgov2014 < > evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org> > Subject: Re: [IGFmaglist] Next Steps: Way Forward Evolution of Internet > Governance Ecosystem/Role of IGF ? (Reaction to NETmundial + CSTD, WSIS, > ITU, other fora.) > > Hi Subi, > > No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. > I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up > doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up > those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be > a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that > this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions > that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for > the general invitation to do so. > > I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main > session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its > description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, > and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. > > I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like > ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: > > >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >> (suggestion) >> >> > then this would remedy my concerns. > > Kind regards > Filiz Yilmaz > > > On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: > > Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as > always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the > nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for > pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , > ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a > separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective > decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have > missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two > separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them > here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall > Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize > and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder > group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of > us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since > this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together > on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG > landscape. > > I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply > insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the > mailing list created for the session. > > The id for the mailing list for this session is > evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > > Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. > > To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines > do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: > > NEXT STEPS:- Action Items > > MAIN FOCUS SESSION: > Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have > signed up. > Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required > but mostly relates to the points above > Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs > required > Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call > Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-8: Feedback and review > > > Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: > >> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco >> is also high priority to include . >> I would suggest slight re formulation >> >> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review >> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) >> NETmundial outputs >> >> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c >> >> Is that what we want to do? >> >> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. >> >> Sent from my iPhone >> >> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" >> wrote: >> >> Dear All, >> >> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have >> indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main >> focus session. >> >> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual >> call. >> >> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus >> session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to >> receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead >> of the next scheduled call. >> >> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been >> identified for this session: >> >> >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap >> >> And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the >> values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, >> integrity, freedom of speech and expression, >> universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation >> and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses >> and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles >> and the internet of the future. >> >> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >> >> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have >> signed up. >> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be >> required but mostly relates to the points above >> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs >> required >> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-8: Feedback and review >> >> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the >> IGF secretariat, as requested. >> >> Some speaker suggestions >> >> >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >> (suggestion) >> >> >> >> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for >> your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >> >> >> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the >> list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >> >> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference >> and committing your time. >> >> List: >> >> 1. Olga Cavall >> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >> 4.Virat Bhatia >> 5.Ana Neves >> 6.Constance Bommelaer >> 7.Kossi Amessinou >> 8.Baher Esmat >> 9.Izumi Aizu >> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >> 11.William Drake >> 12.Jivan >> 13.Patrick Ryan >> 14.Ankhi Das >> 15.Christine Arida >> >> >> warmest >> >> Subi >> ---- >> >> Subi Chaturvedi >> >> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >> >> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >> >> Delhi University, India >> >> M:+91-9999151433 >> >> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >> >> Skype:subi.apex >> >> >> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >> >> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >> >> Convenor WG-India IGF >> >> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >> >> >> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >> >> Media For Change >> >> >> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >> >> The Saltlist >> >> www.thesaltlist.org >> >> >> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >> >> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >> >> >> PhD. Scholar, >> >> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Igfmaglist mailing list >> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >> >> > _______________________________________________ > Igfmaglist mailing list > Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subichaturvedi at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 07:43:09 2014 From: subichaturvedi at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 17:13:09 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_Way_For?= =?utf-8?q?ward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_?= =?utf-8?q?IGF_=E2=80=93_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS?= =?utf-8?q?=2C_ITU=2C_other_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: <4rlpa87cp7drxc3h99tvdscj.1397648113473@email.android.com> References: <4rlpa87cp7drxc3h99tvdscj.1397648113473@email.android.com> Message-ID: Agree Fiona entirely. Have collated the inputs. Do please send in your suggestions too on the session. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 16 April 2014 17:05, Fiona Alexander wrote: > Just to highlight there is far more to ICANN than the IANA transition > issue, perhaps it is to those elements Marilyn and others are pointing to > as including in this session. > > Fiona > > > -------- Original message -------- > From: Subi Chaturvedi > Date:04/16/2014 7:32 AM (GMT-05:00) > To: Filiz Yilmaz > Cc: MAG List IGF ,evolintgov2014 > Subject: Re: [IGFmaglist] Next Steps: Way Forward Evolution of Internet > Governance Ecosystem/Role of IGF ? (Reaction to NETmundial + CSTD, WSIS, > ITU, other fora.) > > Thanks Filiz. Excellent inputs. Let me explain so that we can all be on > the same page. I meant Marilyn might have missed the poll and therefore > might not be aware that there is a separate session dedicated to > specifically the IANA transition/ICANN part of the IG way forward. Your > name you would notice is already a part of the original list on the mail > even in this thread, taken from the doodle poll. so no confusion there. > That also doesn't indicate that other than the volunteers who signed up > the MAG members shouldn't contribute. On the contrary I continue to ask for > inputs from all the MAG members. Additionally I have already requested the > secretariat to add Marilyn to the mailing list created for this session. > > evolintgov2014 > > Your time and your inputs are most valued and deeply appreciated. > > Now here are some quick points on the sessions planing thus far: > > > At stage 1 all these issues were a part of this session, when it was > envisaged originally as one big main . > > At stage 2 and over the virtual call the chair suggested that we keep > the two sessions separate and we decided to have two main sessions on the > Internet ecosystem instead of one, so that we can have a more focused > discussion in both the sessions. I have no preference one way or the other > and we should certainly decided on the strands today if possible over the > virtual call or over emails. > > > All inputs and suggestions are very welcome. You would notice that not > only do I agree that we should have more speakers from all organisations > but also from different stakeholder groups > > .Civil Society/Academia > .Technical community > .Governments > .Private sector > > I continue to ask for names of speakers/ recommendations from all the > organisations and from across stakeholder groups. Excellent suggestions all > from you, Marilyn, Tero, Bill, Izumi and Olga. Thank you all. > > Do please suggest speakers/facilitators and your inputs on the other > items we need to take a decision on. > > Looking forward. > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > Skype:subi.apex > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > On 16 April 2014 16:30, Filiz Yilmaz wrote: > >> Hi Subi, >> >> No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. >> I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up >> doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up >> those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be >> a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that >> this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions >> that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for >> the general invitation to do so. >> >> I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main >> session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its >> description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, >> and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. >> >> I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like >> ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: >> >> >>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >>> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >>> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >>> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >>> (suggestion) >>> >>> >> then this would remedy my concerns. >> >> Kind regards >> Filiz Yilmaz >> >> >> On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi >> wrote: >> >> Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as >> always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the >> nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for >> pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , >> ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a >> separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective >> decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have >> missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two >> separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them >> here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall >> Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize >> and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder >> group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of >> us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since >> this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together >> on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG >> landscape. >> >> I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their >> deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on >> the mailing list created for the session. >> >> The id for the mailing list for this session is >> evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org >> >> Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. >> >> To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the >> timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: >> >> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >> >> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have >> signed up. >> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be >> required but mostly relates to the points above >> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs >> required >> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-8: Feedback and review >> >> >> Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. >> >> >> warmest >> >> Subi >> ---- >> >> Subi Chaturvedi >> >> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >> >> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >> >> Delhi University, India >> >> M:+91-9999151433 >> >> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >> >> >> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >> >> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >> >> Convenor WG-India IGF >> >> Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) >> >> >> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >> >> Media For Change >> >> >> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >> >> The Saltlist >> >> www.thesaltlist.org >> >> >> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, >> >> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >> >> >> PhD. Scholar, >> >> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >> >> >> >> On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: >> >>> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco >>> is also high priority to include . >>> I would suggest slight re formulation >>> >>> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review >>> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) >>> NETmundial outputs >>> >>> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c >>> >>> Is that what we want to do? >>> >>> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. >>> >>> Sent from my iPhone >>> >>> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" >>> wrote: >>> >>> Dear All, >>> >>> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have >>> indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main >>> focus session. >>> >>> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual >>> call. >>> >>> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus >>> session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to >>> receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead >>> of the next scheduled call. >>> >>> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have >>> been identified for this session: >>> >>> >>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the >>> future roadmap >>> >>> And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the >>> values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, >>> integrity, freedom of speech and expression, >>> universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation >>> and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses >>> and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles >>> and the internet of the future. >>> >>> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >>> >>> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >>> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have >>> signed up. >>> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be >>> required but mostly relates to the points above >>> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs >>> required >>> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >>> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-8: Feedback and review >>> >>> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the >>> IGF secretariat, as requested. >>> >>> Some speaker suggestions >>> >>> >>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >>> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >>> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >>> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >>> (suggestion) >>> >>> >>> >>> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for >>> your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >>> >>> >>> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the >>> list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >>> >>> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference >>> and committing your time. >>> >>> List: >>> >>> 1. Olga Cavall >>> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >>> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >>> 4.Virat Bhatia >>> 5.Ana Neves >>> 6.Constance Bommelaer >>> 7.Kossi Amessinou >>> 8.Baher Esmat >>> 9.Izumi Aizu >>> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >>> 11.William Drake >>> 12.Jivan >>> 13.Patrick Ryan >>> 14.Ankhi Das >>> 15.Christine Arida >>> >>> >>> warmest >>> >>> Subi >>> ---- >>> >>> Subi Chaturvedi >>> >>> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >>> >>> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >>> >>> Delhi University, India >>> >>> M:+91-9999151433 >>> >>> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >>> >>> Skype:subi.apex >>> >>> >>> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >>> >>> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >>> >>> Convenor WG-India IGF >>> >>> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >>> >>> >>> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >>> >>> Media For Change >>> >>> >>> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >>> >>> The Saltlist >>> >>> www.thesaltlist.org >>> >>> >>> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >>> >>> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >>> >>> >>> PhD. Scholar, >>> >>> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >>> >>> >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Igfmaglist mailing list >>> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >>> >>> >> _______________________________________________ >> Igfmaglist mailing list >> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >> >> >> > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From koalafil at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 07:00:37 2014 From: koalafil at gmail.com (Filiz Yilmaz) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 13:00:37 +0200 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?windows-1252?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_?= =?windows-1252?q?Way_Forward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/R?= =?windows-1252?q?ole_of_IGF_=96_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS?= =?windows-1252?q?=2C_ITU=2C_other_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> Hi Subi, No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for the general invitation to do so. I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: >> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) then this would remedy my concerns. Kind regards Filiz Yilmaz On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi wrote: > Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG landscape. > > I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the mailing list created for the session. > > The id for the mailing list for this session is evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > > Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. > > To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: > > NEXT STEPS:- Action Items > > MAIN FOCUS SESSION: > Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. > Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above > Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call > Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-8: Feedback and review > > > Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) > > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > > Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > > On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: > I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is also high priority to include . > I would suggest slight re formulation > > Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review > UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) > NETmundial outputs > > Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c > > Is that what we want to do? > > Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" wrote: > >> Dear All, >> >> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main focus session. >> >> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. >> >> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead of the next scheduled call. >> >> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been identified for this session: >> >> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap >> And all of these would lead to best practices related to the core the values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, integrity, freedom of speech and expression, universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles and the internet of the future. >> >> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >> >> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. >> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above >> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-8: Feedback and review >> >> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the IGF secretariat, as requested. >> >> Some speaker suggestions >> >> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) >> >> >> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >> >> >> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >> >> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and committing your time. >> >> List: >> >> 1. Olga Cavall >> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >> 4.Virat Bhatia >> 5.Ana Neves >> 6.Constance Bommelaer >> 7.Kossi Amessinou >> 8.Baher Esmat >> 9.Izumi Aizu >> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >> 11.William Drake >> 12.Jivan >> 13.Patrick Ryan >> 14.Ankhi Das >> 15.Christine Arida >> >> >> warmest >> >> Subi >> ---- >> Subi Chaturvedi >> >> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >> >> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >> >> Delhi University, India >> >> M:+91-9999151433 >> >> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >> >> Skype:subi.apex >> >> >> >> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >> >> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >> >> Convenor WG-India IGF >> >> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >> >> >> >> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >> >> Media For Change >> >> >> >> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >> >> The Saltlist >> >> www.thesaltlist.org >> >> >> >> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >> >> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >> >> >> >> PhD. Scholar, >> >> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >> >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Igfmaglist mailing list >> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > > _______________________________________________ > Igfmaglist mailing list > Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From FAlexander at ntia.doc.gov Wed Apr 16 07:35:17 2014 From: FAlexander at ntia.doc.gov (Fiona Alexander) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 07:35:17 -0400 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D=09Next_Steps=3A_Way_F?= =?utf-8?q?orward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_?= =?utf-8?q?=E2=80=93_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_ot?= =?utf-8?q?her_fora=2E=29?= Message-ID: <4rlpa87cp7drxc3h99tvdscj.1397648113473@email.android.com> Just to highlight there is far more to ICANN than the IANA transition issue, perhaps it is to those elements Marilyn and others are pointing to as including in this session. Fiona -------- Original message -------- From: Subi Chaturvedi Date:04/16/2014 7:32 AM (GMT-05:00) To: Filiz Yilmaz Cc: MAG List IGF ,evolintgov2014 Subject: Re: [IGFmaglist] Next Steps: Way Forward Evolution of Internet Governance Ecosystem/Role of IGF ? (Reaction to NETmundial + CSTD, WSIS, ITU, other fora.) Thanks Filiz. Excellent inputs. Let me explain so that we can all be on the same page. I meant Marilyn might have missed the poll and therefore might not be aware that there is a separate session dedicated to specifically the IANA transition/ICANN part of the IG way forward. Your name you would notice is already a part of the original list on the mail even in this thread, taken from the doodle poll. so no confusion there. That also doesn't indicate that other than the volunteers who signed up the MAG members shouldn't contribute. On the contrary I continue to ask for inputs from all the MAG members. Additionally I have already requested the secretariat to add Marilyn to the mailing list created for this session. evolintgov2014 > Your time and your inputs are most valued and deeply appreciated. Now here are some quick points on the sessions planing thus far: At stage 1 all these issues were a part of this session, when it was envisaged originally as one big main . At stage 2 and over the virtual call the chair suggested that we keep the two sessions separate and we decided to have two main sessions on the Internet ecosystem instead of one, so that we can have a more focused discussion in both the sessions. I have no preference one way or the other and we should certainly decided on the strands today if possible over the virtual call or over emails. All inputs and suggestions are very welcome. You would notice that not only do I agree that we should have more speakers from all organisations but also from different stakeholder groups .Civil Society/Academia .Technical community .Governments .Private sector I continue to ask for names of speakers/ recommendations from all the organisations and from across stakeholder groups. Excellent suggestions all from you, Marilyn, Tero, Bill, Izumi and Olga. Thank you all. Do please suggest speakers/facilitators and your inputs on the other items we need to take a decision on. Looking forward. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 16 April 2014 16:30, Filiz Yilmaz > wrote: Hi Subi, No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for the general invitation to do so. I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) then this would remedy my concerns. Kind regards Filiz Yilmaz On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG landscape. I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the mailing list created for the session. The id for the mailing list for this session is evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: NEXT STEPS:- Action Items MAIN FOCUS SESSION: Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-8: Feedback and review Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade > wrote: I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is also high priority to include . I would suggest slight re formulation Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) NETmundial outputs Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c Is that what we want to do? Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. Sent from my iPhone On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" > wrote: Dear All, Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main focus session. This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead of the next scheduled call. In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been identified for this session: 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap And all of these would lead to best practices related to the core the values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, integrity, freedom of speech and expression, universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles and the internet of the future. NEXT STEPS:- Action Items MAIN FOCUS SESSION: Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required Stage-8: Feedback and review The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the IGF secretariat, as requested. Some speaker suggestions 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and committing your time. List: 1. Olga Cavall 2.Anriette Esterhuyser 3.Subi Chaturvedi 4.Virat Bhatia 5.Ana Neves 6.Constance Bommelaer 7.Kossi Amessinou 8.Baher Esmat 9.Izumi Aizu 10.Shahram Soboutipour 11.William Drake 12.Jivan 13.Patrick Ryan 14.Ankhi Das 15.Christine Arida warmest Subi ---- Subi Chaturvedi Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), Delhi University, India M:+91-9999151433 Twitter:@subichaturvedi Skype:subi.apex Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) Convenor WG-India IGF Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, Media For Change Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor The Saltlist www.thesaltlist.org Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, Curator, Media Critic & Scholar PhD. Scholar, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi _______________________________________________ Igfmaglist mailing list Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org _______________________________________________ Igfmaglist mailing list Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From marilynscade at hotmail.com Wed Apr 16 07:48:51 2014 From: marilynscade at hotmail.com (Marilyn Cade) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 13:48:51 +0200 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_Way_For?= =?utf-8?q?ward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_?= =?utf-8?q?=E2=80=93_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_ot?= =?utf-8?q?her_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> References: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> Message-ID: I want to note that as we have a lot of workshops that have come in on 'our' area, /or related, we may want to take a bit of a pause and consider those, seeing what we can garner or glean from this as a sort of new source of data so to speak, about what will also be happening in workshops, and also the 'feeding in'concept. Workshops /roundtables on this/related will allow for much more direct participation by a broader number of people, if we are careful to ensure a wide diversity of participants/speakers, so much to discuss today and in days ahead. I do apologize for missing the Doodle poll. I look forward to joining team evolintgov2012. :-) M Sent from my iPad > On Apr 16, 2014, at 1:00 PM, "Filiz Yilmaz" wrote: > > Hi Subi, > > No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. > I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for the general invitation to do so. > > I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. > > I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: > >>>> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>>> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>>> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) > > then this would remedy my concerns. > > Kind regards > Filiz Yilmaz > > >> On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi wrote: >> >> Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG landscape. >> >> I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the mailing list created for the session. >> >> The id for the mailing list for this session is evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org >> >> Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. >> >> To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: >> >> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >> >> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. >> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above >> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-8: Feedback and review >> >> >> Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. >> >> >> warmest >> >> Subi >> ---- >> Subi Chaturvedi >> >> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >> >> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >> >> Delhi University, India >> >> M:+91-9999151433 >> >> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >> >> >> >> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >> >> Convenor WG-India IGF >> >> Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) >> >> >> >> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >> >> Media For Change >> >> >> >> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >> >> The Saltlist >> >> www.thesaltlist.org >> >> >> >> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, >> >> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >> >> >> >> PhD. Scholar, >> >> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >> >> >> >> >>> On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: >>> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is also high priority to include . >>> I would suggest slight re formulation >>> >>> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review >>> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) >>> NETmundial outputs >>> >>> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c >>> >>> Is that what we want to do? >>> >>> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. >>> >>> Sent from my iPhone >>> >>>> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" wrote: >>>> >>>> Dear All, >>>> >>>> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main focus session. >>>> >>>> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. >>>> >>>> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead of the next scheduled call. >>>> >>>> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been identified for this session: >>>> >>>> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >>>> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >>>> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap >>>> And all of these would lead to best practices related to the core the values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, integrity, freedom of speech and expression, universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles and the internet of the future. >>>> >>>> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >>>> >>>> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >>>> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. >>>> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above >>>> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >>>> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>> Stage-8: Feedback and review >>>> >>>> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the IGF secretariat, as requested. >>>> >>>> Some speaker suggestions >>>> >>>> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>>> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>>> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) >>>> >>>> >>>> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >>>> >>>> >>>> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >>>> >>>> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and committing your time. >>>> >>>> List: >>>> >>>> 1. Olga Cavall >>>> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >>>> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >>>> 4.Virat Bhatia >>>> 5.Ana Neves >>>> 6.Constance Bommelaer >>>> 7.Kossi Amessinou >>>> 8.Baher Esmat >>>> 9.Izumi Aizu >>>> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >>>> 11.William Drake >>>> 12.Jivan >>>> 13.Patrick Ryan >>>> 14.Ankhi Das >>>> 15.Christine Arida >>>> >>>> >>>> warmest >>>> >>>> Subi >>>> ---- >>>> Subi Chaturvedi >>>> >>>> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >>>> >>>> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >>>> >>>> Delhi University, India >>>> >>>> M:+91-9999151433 >>>> >>>> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >>>> >>>> Skype:subi.apex >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >>>> >>>> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >>>> >>>> Convenor WG-India IGF >>>> >>>> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >>>> >>>> Media For Change >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >>>> >>>> The Saltlist >>>> >>>> www.thesaltlist.org >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >>>> >>>> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> PhD. Scholar, >>>> >>>> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> _______________________________________________ >>>> Igfmaglist mailing list >>>> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >>>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Igfmaglist mailing list >> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From koalafil at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 08:19:11 2014 From: koalafil at gmail.com (Filiz Yilmaz) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 14:19:11 +0200 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_Way_For?= =?utf-8?q?ward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_IGF_?= =?utf-8?q?=E2=80=93_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS=2C_ITU=2C_ot?= =?utf-8?q?her_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> Message-ID: <983CB46B-7F5B-4A21-A7DC-687FD279EB8B@gmail.com> Dear Subi, Just to clarify and make sure there are no unmet expectations, to my knowledge I have not volunteered for this session on the Doodle poll. In fact my response bounced back from the dedicated mailing list you cc'ed, noting that it is awaiting moderation as a post from a non-member. Having said that I repeat that I am happy the group takes input from us too, non-members. Filuz Apologies for the brevity of this mail, it was sent from my iphone > On 16 Apr 2014, at 13:31, Subi Chaturvedi wrote: > > Thanks Filiz. Excellent inputs. Let me explain so that we can all be on the same page. I meant Marilyn might have missed the poll and therefore might not be aware that there is a separate session dedicated to specifically the IANA transition/ICANN part of the IG way forward. Your name you would notice is already a part of the original list on the mail even in this thread, taken from the doodle poll. so no confusion there. That also doesn't indicate that other than the volunteers who signed up the MAG members shouldn't contribute. On the contrary I continue to ask for inputs from all the MAG members. Additionally I have already requested the secretariat to add Marilyn to the mailing list created for this session. > > evolintgov2014 > > Your time and your inputs are most valued and deeply appreciated. > > Now here are some quick points on the sessions planing thus far: > > > At stage 1 all these issues were a part of this session, when it was envisaged originally as one big main . > > At stage 2 and over the virtual call the chair suggested that we keep the two sessions separate and we decided to have two main sessions on the Internet ecosystem instead of one, so that we can have a more focused discussion in both the sessions. I have no preference one way or the other and we should certainly decided on the strands today if possible over the virtual call or over emails. > > > All inputs and suggestions are very welcome. You would notice that not only do I agree that we should have more speakers from all organisations but also from different stakeholder groups > > .Civil Society/Academia > .Technical community > .Governments > .Private sector > > I continue to ask for names of speakers/ recommendations from all the organisations and from across stakeholder groups. Excellent suggestions all from you, Marilyn, Tero, Bill, Izumi and Olga. Thank you all. > > Do please suggest speakers/facilitators and your inputs on the other items we need to take a decision on. > > Looking forward. > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > Skype:subi.apex > > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) > > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > > Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > >> On 16 April 2014 16:30, Filiz Yilmaz wrote: >> Hi Subi, >> >> No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. >> I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for the general invitation to do so. >> >> I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. >> >> I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: >> >>>>> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>>>> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>>>> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) >> >> then this would remedy my concerns. >> >> Kind regards >> Filiz Yilmaz >> >> >>> On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi wrote: >>> >>> Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG landscape. >>> >>> I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the mailing list created for the session. >>> >>> The id for the mailing list for this session is evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org >>> >>> Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. >>> >>> To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: >>> >>> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >>> >>> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >>> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. >>> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above >>> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >>> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-8: Feedback and review >>> >>> >>> Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. >>> >>> >>> warmest >>> >>> Subi >>> ---- >>> Subi Chaturvedi >>> >>> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >>> >>> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >>> >>> Delhi University, India >>> >>> M:+91-9999151433 >>> >>> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >>> >>> >>> >>> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >>> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >>> >>> Convenor WG-India IGF >>> >>> Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) >>> >>> >>> >>> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >>> >>> Media For Change >>> >>> >>> >>> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >>> >>> The Saltlist >>> >>> www.thesaltlist.org >>> >>> >>> >>> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, >>> >>> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >>> >>> >>> >>> PhD. Scholar, >>> >>> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >>> >>> >>> >>> >>>> On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: >>>> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is also high priority to include . >>>> I would suggest slight re formulation >>>> >>>> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review >>>> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) >>>> NETmundial outputs >>>> >>>> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c >>>> >>>> Is that what we want to do? >>>> >>>> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. >>>> >>>> Sent from my iPhone >>>> >>>>> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" wrote: >>>>> >>>>> Dear All, >>>>> >>>>> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main focus session. >>>>> >>>>> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. >>>>> >>>>> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead of the next scheduled call. >>>>> >>>>> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been identified for this session: >>>>> >>>>> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >>>>> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >>>>> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap >>>>> And all of these would lead to best practices related to the core the values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, integrity, freedom of speech and expression, universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles and the internet of the future. >>>>> >>>>> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >>>>> >>>>> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >>>>> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have signed up. >>>>> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required but mostly relates to the points above >>>>> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>>> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>>> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>>> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >>>>> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>>>> Stage-8: Feedback and review >>>>> >>>>> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the IGF secretariat, as requested. >>>>> >>>>> Some speaker suggestions >>>>> >>>>> UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>>>> ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>>>> Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) (suggestion) >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >>>>> >>>>> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and committing your time. >>>>> >>>>> List: >>>>> >>>>> 1. Olga Cavall >>>>> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >>>>> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >>>>> 4.Virat Bhatia >>>>> 5.Ana Neves >>>>> 6.Constance Bommelaer >>>>> 7.Kossi Amessinou >>>>> 8.Baher Esmat >>>>> 9.Izumi Aizu >>>>> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >>>>> 11.William Drake >>>>> 12.Jivan >>>>> 13.Patrick Ryan >>>>> 14.Ankhi Das >>>>> 15.Christine Arida >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> warmest >>>>> >>>>> Subi >>>>> ---- >>>>> Subi Chaturvedi >>>>> >>>>> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >>>>> >>>>> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >>>>> >>>>> Delhi University, India >>>>> >>>>> M:+91-9999151433 >>>>> >>>>> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >>>>> >>>>> Skype:subi.apex >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >>>>> >>>>> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >>>>> >>>>> Convenor WG-India IGF >>>>> >>>>> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >>>>> >>>>> Media For Change >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >>>>> >>>>> The Saltlist >>>>> >>>>> www.thesaltlist.org >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >>>>> >>>>> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> PhD. Scholar, >>>>> >>>>> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> _______________________________________________ >>>>> Igfmaglist mailing list >>>>> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >>>>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Igfmaglist mailing list >>> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From fatimacambronero at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 08:22:30 2014 From: fatimacambronero at gmail.com (Fatima Cambronero) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 09:22:30 -0300 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] [IGFmaglist] Next Steps: Way Forward Evolution of Internet Governance Ecosystem/Role of IGF - (Reaction to NETmundial + CSTD, WSIS, ITU, other fora.) In-Reply-To: <983CB46B-7F5B-4A21-A7DC-687FD279EB8B@gmail.com> References: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> <983CB46B-7F5B-4A21-A7DC-687FD279EB8B@gmail.com> Message-ID: +1 Filiz Fatima 2014-04-16 9:19 GMT-03:00 Filiz Yilmaz : > Dear Subi, > > Just to clarify and make sure there are no unmet expectations, to my > knowledge I have not volunteered for this session on the Doodle poll. In > fact my response bounced back from the dedicated mailing list you cc'ed, > noting that it is awaiting moderation as a post from a non-member. > > Having said that I repeat that I am happy the group takes input from us > too, non-members. > > Filuz > > Apologies for the brevity of this mail, it was sent from my iphone > > On 16 Apr 2014, at 13:31, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: > > Thanks Filiz. Excellent inputs. Let me explain so that we can all be on > the same page. I meant Marilyn might have missed the poll and therefore > might not be aware that there is a separate session dedicated to > specifically the IANA transition/ICANN part of the IG way forward. Your > name you would notice is already a part of the original list on the mail > even in this thread, taken from the doodle poll. so no confusion there. > That also doesn't indicate that other than the volunteers who signed up > the MAG members shouldn't contribute. On the contrary I continue to ask for > inputs from all the MAG members. Additionally I have already requested the > secretariat to add Marilyn to the mailing list created for this session. > > evolintgov2014 > > Your time and your inputs are most valued and deeply appreciated. > > Now here are some quick points on the sessions planing thus far: > > > At stage 1 all these issues were a part of this session, when it was > envisaged originally as one big main . > > At stage 2 and over the virtual call the chair suggested that we keep the > two sessions separate and we decided to have two main sessions on the > Internet ecosystem instead of one, so that we can have a more focused > discussion in both the sessions. I have no preference one way or the other > and we should certainly decided on the strands today if possible over the > virtual call or over emails. > > > All inputs and suggestions are very welcome. You would notice that not > only do I agree that we should have more speakers from all organisations > but also from different stakeholder groups > > .Civil Society/Academia > .Technical community > .Governments > .Private sector > > I continue to ask for names of speakers/ recommendations from all the > organisations and from across stakeholder groups. Excellent suggestions all > from you, Marilyn, Tero, Bill, Izumi and Olga. Thank you all. > > Do please suggest speakers/facilitators and your inputs on the other items > we need to take a decision on. > > Looking forward. > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > Skype:subi.apex > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > On 16 April 2014 16:30, Filiz Yilmaz wrote: > >> Hi Subi, >> >> No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. >> I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up >> doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up >> those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be >> a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that >> this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions >> that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for >> the general invitation to do so. >> >> I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main >> session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap" in its >> description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, >> and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. >> >> I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like >> ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc... further on the following: >> >> >>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >>> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >>> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >>> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >>> (suggestion) >>> >>> >> then this would remedy my concerns. >> >> Kind regards >> Filiz Yilmaz >> >> >> On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi >> wrote: >> >> Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as >> always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the >> nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for >> pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , >> ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a >> separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective >> decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have >> missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two >> separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them >> here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall >> Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize >> and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder >> group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of >> us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since >> this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together >> on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG >> landscape. >> >> I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply >> insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the >> mailing list created for the session. >> >> The id for the mailing list for this session is >> evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org >> >> Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. >> >> To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines >> do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: >> >> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >> >> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have >> signed up. >> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be >> required but mostly relates to the points above >> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs >> required >> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-8: Feedback and review >> >> >> Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. >> >> >> warmest >> >> Subi >> ---- >> >> Subi Chaturvedi >> >> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >> >> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >> >> Delhi University, India >> >> M:+91-9999151433 >> >> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >> >> >> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >> >> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >> >> Convenor WG-India IGF >> >> Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) >> >> >> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >> >> Media For Change >> >> >> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >> >> The Saltlist >> >> www.thesaltlist.org >> >> >> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, >> >> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >> >> >> PhD. Scholar, >> >> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >> >> >> >> On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: >> >>> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco >>> is also high priority to include . >>> I would suggest slight re formulation >>> >>> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review >>> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) >>> NETmundial outputs >>> >>> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c >>> >>> Is that what we want to do? >>> >>> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. >>> >>> Sent from my iPhone >>> >>> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" >>> wrote: >>> >>> Dear All, >>> >>> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have >>> indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main >>> focus session. >>> >>> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual >>> call. >>> >>> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus >>> session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to >>> receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead >>> of the next scheduled call. >>> >>> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been >>> identified for this session: >>> >>> >>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the >>> future roadmap >>> >>> And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the >>> values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, >>> integrity, freedom of speech and expression, >>> universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation >>> and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses >>> and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles >>> and the internet of the future. >>> >>> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >>> >>> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >>> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have >>> signed up. >>> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be >>> required but mostly relates to the points above >>> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs >>> required >>> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >>> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >>> Stage-8: Feedback and review >>> >>> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the >>> IGF secretariat, as requested. >>> >>> Some speaker suggestions >>> >>> >>> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >>> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >>> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >>> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >>> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >>> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >>> (suggestion) >>> >>> >>> >>> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your >>> constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >>> >>> >>> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the >>> list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >>> >>> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and >>> committing your time. >>> >>> List: >>> >>> 1. Olga Cavall >>> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >>> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >>> 4.Virat Bhatia >>> 5.Ana Neves >>> 6.Constance Bommelaer >>> 7.Kossi Amessinou >>> 8.Baher Esmat >>> 9.Izumi Aizu >>> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >>> 11.William Drake >>> 12.Jivan >>> 13.Patrick Ryan >>> 14.Ankhi Das >>> 15.Christine Arida >>> >>> >>> warmest >>> >>> Subi >>> ---- >>> >>> Subi Chaturvedi >>> >>> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >>> >>> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >>> >>> Delhi University, India >>> >>> M:+91-9999151433 >>> >>> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >>> >>> Skype:subi.apex >>> >>> >>> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >>> >>> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >>> >>> Convenor WG-India IGF >>> >>> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >>> >>> >>> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >>> >>> Media For Change >>> >>> >>> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >>> >>> The Saltlist >>> >>> www.thesaltlist.org >>> >>> >>> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >>> >>> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >>> >>> >>> PhD. Scholar, >>> >>> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >>> >>> >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Igfmaglist mailing list >>> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >>> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >>> >>> >> _______________________________________________ >> Igfmaglist mailing list >> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >> >> >> > > _______________________________________________ > Igfmaglist mailing list > Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > > -- *Fatima Cambronero* Abogada-Argentina Phone: +54 9351 5282 668 Twitter: @facambronero Skype: fatima.cambronero -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From subi.lsr at gmail.com Wed Apr 16 11:25:29 2014 From: subi.lsr at gmail.com (Subi Chaturvedi) Date: Wed, 16 Apr 2014 20:55:29 +0530 Subject: [Evolintgov2014] =?utf-8?q?=5BIGFmaglist=5D_Next_Steps=3A_Way_For?= =?utf-8?q?ward_Evolution_of_Internet_Governance_Ecosystem/Role_of_?= =?utf-8?q?IGF_=E2=80=93_=28Reaction_to_NETmundial_+_CSTD=2C_WSIS?= =?utf-8?q?=2C_ITU=2C_other_fora=2E=29?= In-Reply-To: References: <8B3F7D33-971E-4694-95AA-7D6F95D715AA@gmail.com> Message-ID: Thanks Marilyn. I am at subichaturvedi at gmail.com Again good inputs. Let's also hear more from the other MAG members and those on the volunteer list for the session. I am hopeful that we'll receive more inputs and suggestions on the way forward for this session. And then then reassess in a couple of days. warmest Subi On Wed, Apr 16, 2014 at 5:18 PM, Marilyn Cade wrote: > I want to note that as we have a lot of workshops that have come in on > 'our' area, /or related, we may want to take a bit of a pause and consider > those, seeing what we can garner or glean from this as a sort of new source > of data so to speak, about what will also be happening in workshops, and > also the 'feeding in'concept. > > Workshops /roundtables on this/related will allow for much more direct > participation by a broader number of people, if we are careful to ensure a > wide diversity of participants/speakers, so much to discuss today and in > days ahead. > > I do apologize for missing the Doodle poll. > > I look forward to joining team evolintgov2012. > > :-) > > M > Sent from my iPad > > On Apr 16, 2014, at 1:00 PM, "Filiz Yilmaz" wrote: > > Hi Subi, > > No, I have not missed the Doodle poll and I provided my preferences. > I believe it is not good practice to stretch oneself out thin and end up > doing half a job so I have not volunteered to all sessions but picked up > those I thought I could provide the best contribution to. This seems to be > a shared strategy by most, looking at the Doddle poll. Having said that > this should not stop anyone providing further input even for the sessions > that they have not volunteered for and so thank you for your kind mail for > the general invitation to do so. > > I would follow-up on my support for what has been said that this main > session bares "Evolution of the Internet and the future roadmap? in its > description. And by definition this cannot be limited to WSIS, CSTD, IGF, > and even NetMundial etc.. , as we make a listing in that detail. > > I think if there are speakers from other Internet organisations like > ICANN, NRO, IETF, ISOC, etc? further on the following: > > >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >> (suggestion) >> >> > then this would remedy my concerns. > > Kind regards > Filiz Yilmaz > > > On 16 Apr 2014, at 12:47, Subi Chaturvedi > wrote: > > Thanks Marilyn. Tero and Filiz. Excellent inputs all. We benefit, as > always greatly Marilyn from your experience and your ability to hit the > nail on the head. All the strands remain important and thanks Marilyn for > pointing out the very significant additional strands. W3C in particular , > ICANN and IETF as well which are equally significant. But as there is a > separate session on ICANN and IANA transition it was the collective > decision of the MAG and the secretariat to keep them separate. You may have > missed the expression of interest doodle poll, where they are listed as two > separate sessions. However, I am sure we will be able to integrate them > here as well and respond to key questions they pose for the overall > Internet ecosystem but due to paucity of time, we will need to prioritize > and balance all the strands, as well as speakers from each stakeholder > group. All the decisions should and must be taken collectively by all 16 of > us who volunteered with inputs from all the MAG members, especially since > this is in the run up to 2015, we must send a strong message out together > on the contribution and the significance of IGF as well in the overall IG > landscape. > > I am deeply pleased and grateful to all the MAG members for their deeply > insightful inputs and excellent suggestions on the MAG list and on the > mailing list created for the session. > > The id for the mailing list for this session is > evolintgov2014 at intgovforum.org > > Thank you Chengetai and the secretariat for facilitating the engagement. > > To avoid cross postings and in the interest of keeping to the timelines > do please keep sending your inputs on but not limited to: > > NEXT STEPS:- Action Items > > MAIN FOCUS SESSION: > Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have > signed up. > Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be required > but mostly relates to the points above > Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs > required > Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call > Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required > Stage-8: Feedback and review > > > Many thanks again. Looking forward to hearing more from all of you. > > > warmest > > Subi > ---- > > Subi Chaturvedi > > Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, > > Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), > > Delhi University, India > > M:+91-9999151433 > > Twitter:@subichaturvedi > > > Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) > > Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) > > Convenor WG-India IGF > > Co-Chair, Netmundial Brazil (Civil Society) > > > Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, > > Media For Change > > > Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor > > The Saltlist > > www.thesaltlist.org > > > Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer, > > Curator, Media Critic & Scholar > > > PhD. Scholar, > > Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi > > > > On 15 April 2014 02:46, Marilyn Cade wrote: > >> I think e are too narrow re UN agencies and too focused on ITU. Unesco is >> also high priority to include . >> I would suggest slight re formulation >> >> Post WSIS (CSTD WG EC, WSIS+10 review >> UN strand (ITU relevant activities: WTDC, PP, UNESCO) >> NETmundial outputs >> >> Note this ignores ICANN , ITEF, w3c >> >> Is that what we want to do? >> >> Right now this session is a little IGO dominated. >> >> Sent from my iPhone >> >> On Apr 14, 2014, at 22:17, "Subi Chaturvedi" >> wrote: >> >> Dear All, >> >> Further to the Doodle poll delighted to see that 16 MAG members have >> indicated their willingness to facilitate the IGF and way forward main >> focus session. >> >> This is in continuation with my previous mail, following the virtual call. >> >> And to seek inputs and suggesions in the planning of the Main Focus >> session, IGF& The Future of the Internet ecosystem. Would be delighted to >> receive inputs so that they can be collated for the May meeting and ahead >> of the next scheduled call. >> >> In agreement with Janis's excellent inputs, three key strands have been >> identified for this session: >> >> >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 - Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap >> >> And all of these would lead to *best practices* related to the core the >> values of the internet including but not limited to openness, inclusivity, >> integrity, freedom of speech and expression, >> universality, interlopability, permissionless innovation >> and multistakeholderism. And respond to challenges, conflicts, discourses >> and way forward for an evolving internet ecosystem including IG principles >> and the internet of the future. >> >> NEXT STEPS:- Action Items >> >> MAIN FOCUS SESSION: >> Stage-1: call for volunteers and co-facilitators- DONE. !6 of us have >> signed up. >> Stage-2: Short listing of strands/themes:- More discussion may be >> required but mostly relates to the points above >> Stage-3: Identification of Format: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-4: Call for Policy questions: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-5: Resource persons, speakers, facilitators: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs >> required >> Stage-6: Readout for Best practices forum: Volunteer call >> Stage-7: Report: SUGGESTIONS/Inputs required >> Stage-8: Feedback and review >> >> The Main is slotted for DAY III morning, very kindly by the >> IGF secretariat, as requested. >> >> Some speaker suggestions >> >> >> 1. UN Strand (WSIS, CSTD, IGF): Peter Major and Janis Karklins (may >> be requested if they consent (suggestion) >> 2. ITU Strand (WTDC and PP-14); Dr Hamadoun I. Tour?, >> Secretary-General ITU (suggestion) >> 3. Netmundial - Brazil 2014 -Evolution of the Internet and the >> future roadmap: Virgilio A. F. Almeida (Chair- Netmundial) >> (suggestion) >> >> >> >> Looking forward to hearing from all you and thank you as always for your >> constructive feedback and valuable inputs. >> >> >> Also many thanks Kossi for expressing your availability earlier on the >> list. Looking forward to your inputs/suggestions too. >> >> Happy to have all of you. Many thanks for indicating your preference and >> committing your time. >> >> List: >> >> 1. Olga Cavall >> 2.Anriette Esterhuyser >> 3.Subi Chaturvedi >> 4.Virat Bhatia >> 5.Ana Neves >> 6.Constance Bommelaer >> 7.Kossi Amessinou >> 8.Baher Esmat >> 9.Izumi Aizu >> 10.Shahram Soboutipour >> 11.William Drake >> 12.Jivan >> 13.Patrick Ryan >> 14.Ankhi Das >> 15.Christine Arida >> >> >> warmest >> >> Subi >> ---- >> >> Subi Chaturvedi >> >> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm, >> >> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR), >> >> Delhi University, India >> >> M:+91-9999151433 >> >> Twitter:@subichaturvedi >> >> Skype:subi.apex >> >> >> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society) >> >> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society) >> >> Convenor WG-India IGF >> >> Co-Chair, Netmundial, Brazil (Civil Society) >> >> >> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee, >> >> Media For Change >> >> >> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor >> >> The Saltlist >> >> www.thesaltlist.org >> >> >> Independent Documentary Filmmaker, Photographer, >> >> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar >> >> >> PhD. Scholar, >> >> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Igfmaglist mailing list >> Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org >> http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org >> >> > _______________________________________________ > Igfmaglist mailing list > Igfmaglist at intgovforum.org > http://mail.intgovforum.org/mailman/listinfo/igfmaglist_intgovforum.org > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: